Error, bias and validity in qualitative research nigel norris university of east anglia, norwich, united kingdom at its most rudimentary, validity refers to the reasons we have for believing truth claims, what dewey called warranted assertibility phillips, 1987. This article looks at the unique problems that researchers face carrying out participant observation po in fields where criminal activity is commonplace and where participation can often mean breaking the law. Participant observation is a research method which has its roots in anthropology which is a social science which studies the origins and social relationships of human beings and culture. Covert participant observation pearsons 2009 covert participant. Anthropologists are divided on epistemological issues, but almost all of us use the strategic method of participant observation to collect our primary data. Jan 15, 2014 this is an example of types of information that can be observed during participant observation for the research. From participant observation to observant participation. Understanding participatory action research macdonald 37 framework for par encompasses a cyclical process of fact finding, action, reflection, leading to further inquiry and action for change minkler, 2000, p. Participant observation is a type of research strategy.
During participant observation, the researcher works to play two separate roles at the same time. Alternatively, you can download the pdf file directly to your computer, from where it can be opened using a pdf reader. Naturalistic observation is a technique for the collection of data that are, in the ideal at least, as unobtrusive as possible. This post provides some more recent examples of research studies which employed participant observation as their main research method. In claire dwyer and melanie limb eds, qualitative methods for geographers, arnold, london. Participant observation is a research method which involves getting to know the people or culture of those who are being observed and studied as the researcher. Secondly, participant observation obliges the fieldworker to take into account all aspects of a particular community of people. Introduction all methods involve observation, but participant observation is characterized by the extent to which its advocates insist on observation and interpretation of a situation, informed by an understanding of the situation from the point of view of the participants rather than the observer. Participant observation of the interaction in an engineering lab to. More commonly, however, it is viewed positivistically as useful during the preliminary stages of scientific inquiry for exploration and description lazarsfeld, 1972. Observation field research types of observation non participant participant covert ethnography examples participant observation study on sex workers covert non participant observation study on tea rooms covert non participant observation stud y on surfers and drug use participant observation study on mens drumming organizations. This method involves the immersion of the researcher in the subject matter so that it can be observed in its natural setting. Observation field research types of observation nonparticipant participant covert ethnography examples participant observation study on sex workers covert nonparticipant observation study on tea rooms covert nonparticipant observation stud y on surfers and drug use participant observation study on mens drumming organizations. Participantobservation is a method where researchers choose to live directly in the cultural group they are studying.
On the contrary, participant observation is a complex method that has many components. Observation is used in the social sciences as a metho d for collecting data about people, processes, and cultures. The history of participant observation as a method participant observation is considered a staple in anthropological studies, especially in ethnographic studies, and has been used as a data collection method for over a century. Despite the growing tendency to adopt participant observation strategies in health care research regarding healthrelated beliefs and types of behavior, the use of participant observation in current research is mostly limited to structured clinical settings rather than community. Doing ethnographies is an introductory and applied guide to ethnographic methods. Just as the anthropologist brings to the situation certain inherent, if unconscious, cultural biases, so also is he influenced by the.
Sep 03, 2015 this feature is not available right now. Spradley 1980 provides five different types of participant. It is not necessary to think naively in terms of naturally occurring communities or isolated populations, nor do we need to entertain romantic visions of social exploration, in order to insist on the continued importance of participant observation in, and. Participant observation nsuworks nova southeastern university. Even anthropologists who use questionnaires in their research engage first in participant observation in order to build the questionnaire instrument. Participant observation as a data collection method kawulich. Danahay, 1997 which has been encouraged by postmodern theory to draw out the narrative of participant observation and relationships in the field through personal stories of the researcher as a reliable mode of expressing findings from the field coffey, 1999 and as a credible, adjunct data source possick, 2009. Sometimes people are explicitly covert during parts of their research and do not inform those they are observing of their study cook 1997. Participant observation is one the main research methods on the a level sociology syllabus, but many of the examples in the main text books are painfully out of date. This method, called participantobservation, while necessary and useful for gaining a thorough understanding of a foreign culture, is in practice quite difficult. Qualitative and quantitative research paradigms in business research. Participant observation advantages and disadvantages essay 1505 words 7 pages.
This paper provides a look at various definitions of participant observation, the history of its use, the purposes for which it is used, the stances of the. The pros and cons of participant observation or surveys as a research method 1937 words 8 pages. Pdf there is a strong tradition of observational research in most areas of the social sciences. Some observations are carried out without the researcher participating. Mar 31, 2016 participant observation is where the researcher joins in with the group being studied and observes their behaviour. Read participant observation a methodology for human studies by dr. As an anthro major who has done a lot in the discipline, but never had an explicit text that put all the info and strategies on participant observation in one place before, i love this book. Conducting classroom observations in first things first. Pdf participant observation as ethnography or ethnography as. Taking a thoroughly practical approach to the methods of participant observation, jorgensen illustrates these methods with both classic and current research studies.
Finally, it is well known that the presence of an observer will change to at least some extent the context. Participant observation or personal life, taking on a small task that benefits the group to be observed, and staying in the field long enough for habituation to occur. The observation process is a threestage funnel, according to james spradley, beginning with. Settings and procedure based on an initial scoping exercise examining all the possible types of places and environments that house fruit machines, and guidance from preliminary informants, four key types of setting were selected for observation in our research. Nonparticipant observation involves observing participants without actively participating. The natural behaviour of the respondent can be studied by participant observation. Participant observation as a data collection method. Participant observation and nonparticipant observation. Kandace brigleb how participant observation makes for killer web design duration. While providing an introduction to basic principles and strategies, this volume also explores the philosophy and methodology underlying the actual practice of participant observation. This component supplies a dimension of information that is lacking in survey data.
Pdf participant observation as a data collection method. The sage encyclopedia of qualitative research methods. Participant observation is a method of collecting qualitative data in social research. Non participant observation involves observing participants without actively participating. Participant observation one type of data collection method typically done in the qualitative research widely used methodology in many disciplines, particularly anthropology, sociology, communication studies, human geography and social psychology aim is to gain a close and intimate familiarity with a given group of individuals such as a. Sociologists also conducted participant observation studies and discussed the use of the technique early on, including beatrice webb 1926 in the 1880s and the chicago school of urban sociolo gists in. Participant observation is a method of social research that attempts to observe at first hand social action in its everyday or naturalistic setting thereby providing insights into actors meanings and perspectives by bringing the sociologist closer to the social world than other methods.
In participant observation, the researcher himherself is a part of group under study while in non participant observation. This text is a follow up to spradleys earlier ethographic research handbook, the ethnographic interview, and guides students through the technique of participant observation to research ethnography and culture. This post covers the theoretical, practical and ethical strengths and limitations of using overt and covert participant observation in social research. The emergence of narrative ethnography1 barbara tedlock department of anthropology, state university of new york at buffalo, buffalo, ny 14261 beginning in the 1970s there has been a shift in cultural anthropological methodology. By living and immersing oneself within a culture for a long period of time, participantobservation allows anthropologists to get deeper into the complexity of culture. Participant observation advantages and disadvantages. When a group knows that they are going to be observed by a stranger, they feel conscious, uncomfortable and therefore neutrality in their behaviour and activity is lost. Source for information on nonparticipant observation. It does not intend to revisit the wellworn arguments concerning the ethics of covert participant observation cpo, although as. It focuses on those methods participant observation, interviewing, focus groups, and videophotographic work that allow us to understand the lived, everyday world. Conducting observational research deakin university. Qualitative descriptions generated by participant observation are used to formulate. Field notes and participant observation in ethnographic studies.
The length of the observation periods, the interval between them, the number of observations, the area or situation of observation and various techniques used for observation are carefully planned. They mentioned two other approaches that can be used as part of participant observation studies or case studies, or. Aug 16, 2019 participant observation requires the researcher to be a subjective participant in the sense that they use knowledge gained through personal involvement with the research subjects to interact with and gain further access to the group. Par then offers a radical alternative to knowledge development in its. Participant observation chapter 4 of crang and cook herbert, steve 2000 for ethnography. Community based participatory research, participant observation. These truth claims may take the form of statements of fact, descriptions.
A guide for students doing a research project, eds. This type of methodology is employed in many disciplines, particularly anthropology incl. Observation, participant bibliography 1 participant observation was introduced into anthropology at the beginning of the twentieth century when bronislaw malinowski 2 18841942 challenged the traditional paradigm of researchers conducting their studies from the veranda of a missionary sta. This working paper presents findings from a classroom observation study conducted as part of a larger study of first things first, a wholeschool reform model that was developed by the institute for research and reform in education irre and originally mounted in kansas city, kansas. Although the modern technology and research methodology develop in a high speed, participant observation is still the most basic commonly method which could continue being used in the future. The participant observation approach will be casual, relaxed, and friendly as the observer spends time with the participant when the participant goes about her normal activities.
Structured nonparticipant observation in education. Such naturalistic observation is therefore an integral part of ethnographic fieldwork. The bobo doll experiment bandura 1961 reference iv a young girl hitting bobo a young boy pointing a gun at bobo bandura 1961 is a perfect example of a nonparticipant observation investigation. This option is used to understand a phenomenon by entering the community or social system involved, while staying separate from the activities being observed. Participant observation elicits unique observation data from both an insiders and an outsiders perspectives. The participant observation method, also known as ethnographic research, is when a sociologist actually becomes a part of the group they are studying in order to collect data and understand a social phenomenon or problem. Observation, particularl y participant observation, has been the hallmark. However, the participant observation was not lost its own glory because of its ancient. Participant observation involves the observer being a member of the setting in which they are collecting data there are quite a few variations of this definition observation is normally associated with an ethnographic methodology more later but can be used as part of other research designs. Challenges of introducing participant observation to. Par then offers a radical alternative to knowledge development in its mandate to remain a collective, self.
Spradley also teaches students how to analyze the data they collect, and write an ethnography. Id insist on doing all the cooking and itd all have to. Consider the accessibility of the populations and the venues in which you would like to observe them. Pdf participant observation approaches have been important. Participant observation is closely related to the ethnographic method or ethnography, which consists of an indepth study. Participant observation in social research revisesociology. Mar 12, 2007 doing ethnographies is an introductory and applied guide to ethnographic methods. Preparing for participant observation steps determine the purpose of the participant observation activity as related to the overall research objectives. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. A critical analysis of the intercultural communication training industry thesis submitted by rhian morgan bahons uk in january 2010 for the degree of master by research anthropology james cook university, townsville. Participant observation perhaps is the earliest method in the world. Participant observation qualitative research guide.
Participant observation is one type of data collection method by practitionerscholars typically used in qualitative research and ethnography. Participant observations are used to gain insight into cultural practices and phenomena. In this piece we examine the nature of participant observation, the various social roles that researchers can take. This method, called participant observation, while necessary and useful for gaining a thorough understanding of a foreign culture, is in practice quite difficult. Participant observation is a central and defining method of research in cultural anthropology, as well as a common feature of qualitative research in a number of other disciplines sociology, education, health sciences. The basic prerriise guiding our investigation is the belief that the role of the participant observer is subject to two types of social force present in the setting, one stemming from predetermined environmental factors, and a second created through social in. Participant observation is where the researcher joins in with the group being studied and observes their behaviour. Participant observation northern arizona university. Nice concise chapters with lots of information, little fluff and truthfully enjoyable to read. Other researchers have used a more direct observational strategy for studying gangs. Some of the characteristics of observation method of data collection are as follows. There are several reasons the researcher might choose to do this, one because it eliminates the risk that people will be affected by the presence of a researcher, or it could be that the groups might be unwilling to cooperate in research if you participate in. Debating the superiority of methods, or pitting participant observation against. Pdf qualitative and quantitative research paradigms in.
In addition to participant observation and archival research, the study of female teach ers used indepth interviewing. Ofsted inspectors have half a dozen criteria to look out for and grade each criteria 14, with 1 being outstanding and 4 meaning unsatisfactory. Observation, particularly participant observation, has been used in a variety of disciplines as a tool for collecting data about people, processes, and cultures in qualitative research. It is a widely used methodology in many disciplines, particularly, cultural anthropology, but also sociology, communication studies, and social psychology. Informed by the authors fieldwork experience, the book covers the relation between theory, practice and writing, and demonstrates how. The pros and cons of participant observation essay bartleby. Participant observation in organizational research. Field notes and participant observation in ethnographic. Page 4 of 4 the sage encyclopedia of qualitative research methods. Participant observation advantages and disadvantages 8 august 2016 all methods involve observation, but participant observation is characterized by the extent to which its advocates insist on observation and interpretation of a situation, informed by an understanding of the situation from.
1451 976 383 287 1194 1440 1369 878 363 847 649 1196 1419 651 626 484 112 549 264 1369 1360 54 259 679 1264 183 766 143 710 977 18 570 673 243 98 758 1535 291 722 1178 622 516 1285 1000 547 1125 1159 991 928